Why Film Thickness Strongly Affects Measured Surface Resistivity in graphene nanoplatelet systems

Introduction

Film thickness controls measured surface resistivity because thin films change the dominant conduction mechanism from continuous-network (percolative) transport to surface-limited, contact- and tunneling-dominated transport. Graphene nanoplatelets (GNPs, few-layer graphene) form high-aspect-ratio conductive pathways when present in sufficient vertical and lateral connectivity; below a critical thickness the network is incomplete in the out-of-plane direction and measured resistance is dominated by inter-platelet contact resistance and tunnelling gaps. Measurement geometry and electrode spacing set the sampled volume, so a thin layer that looks continuous in topography can still be electrically discontinuous because the number of overlapping platelets through the film thickness is too small. The effect is compounded by aggregation, film porosity, and substrate coupling, which change local field lines and effective probe contact area. Boundary: this explanation applies to thin conductive coatings and composite surface layers (sub-micron to low tens of microns) on insulating substrates used for ESD/anti-static surfaces; it does not describe bulk, millimeter-thick conductive parts where through-thickness percolation is fully established. Evidence on platelet morphology, surface area and percolation thresholds for GNP/FLG supports the mechanism description (see referenced literature such as exfoliated FLG layer-count and BET/SAA characterizations).

Read more on the material page: https://www.greatkela.com/en/product/Carbon_Allotropes/242.html

Common Failure Modes

Primary Failure Modes

• Observed: Surface resistivity is high and variable across parts even at nominally identical loading. Mechanism mismatch: measured area lacks through-thickness overlap of graphene platelets, so conduction is limited by inter-sheet contact resistance and tunnelling gaps rather than an extended conductive network; as a result, spatial variations in microstructure produce local variations in measured resistivity. See also: Why particulate conductive fillers (e.g., carbon black) rapidly increase viscosity in conductive coatings in graphene nanoplatelet systems.
• Observed: Resistivity increases after abrasion or solvent wiping. Mechanism mismatch: conductive pathways are surface-localized and rely on loosely-adhered platelets or binder-rich surface; mechanical removal severs the sparse contacts because the film thickness provided only a single or few platelet layers. See also: Why Carbon Black Eliminates Transparency or Clean Color in Anti-Static Coatings in graphene nanoplatelet systems.
• Observed: Large scatter between two-point and four-point measurements or between different probe pressures. Mechanism mismatch: probe contact resistance and surface roughness become comparable to film sheet resistance for thin films; therefore measurement artefacts dominate when film thickness is too small relative to probe indentation and asperity scale.

Secondary Failure Modes

• Observed: Apparent percolation at some areas but insulating behaviour at others (patchy conduction). Mechanism mismatch: non-uniform thickness, local aggregation, or porosity means some regions exceed the local percolation threshold while adjacent regions do not; as a result ensemble-averaged surface resistivity is dominated by the insulating patches.
• Observed: Rapid humidity dependence of surface resistivity in thin coatings. Mechanism mismatch: thin films permit adsorbed moisture to influence surface conduction pathways (ionic/adsorbate conduction) because the true electronic network is incomplete; therefore environmental conduction mechanisms mask intrinsic percolation behaviour.

Conditions That Change the Outcome

Primary Drivers

• Variable: Film thickness (absolute). Why it matters: because the number of platelet overlaps and parallel conduction channels scales with thickness, increasing probability of continuous through-thickness networks and reducing the relative contribution of inter-platelet contact and tunnelling resistances.
• Variable: Loading fraction and local volume fraction. Why it matters: because percolation threshold for high-aspect-ratio platelets depends on areal and volumetric concentration; for a fixed lateral packing a thicker film reduces the required lateral loading to reach percolation by providing vertical stacking opportunities.
• Variable: Lateral platelet size and aspect ratio. Why it matters: larger lateral size increases probability of overlap at a given thickness, therefore the same film thickness yields lower resistivity for higher aspect ratio platelets due to greater network connectivity (supported by platelet size distribution data).

Secondary Drivers

• Variable: Dispersion / aggregation state. Why it matters: aggregated stacks reduce effective surface area and create local thick islands separated by thin or empty regions; therefore film thickness alone is not predictive unless dispersion uniformity is controlled.
• Variable: Substrate conductivity and surface energy. Why it matters: conductive or leaky substrates change current paths and effective probe coupling; high surface energy substrates can improve wetting and produce thinner, denser films for the same coating process, therefore altering measured resistivity.
• Variable: Measurement method and electrode spacing (two-point vs four-point, probe pressure). Why it matters: electrode geometry determines the sampled lateral scale and depth; thin films are more sensitive to contact resistance and probe indentation, therefore choice of measurement alters the apparent thickness dependence.

How This Differs From Other Approaches

• Percolative network conduction (GNP/FLG networks): conduction occurs because overlapping high-aspect-ratio platelets create continuous electronic paths; thickness increases the number of overlaps and parallel paths and therefore shifts the system from tunnelling/contact-limited to network-limited.
• Surface-limited contact/tunnelling conduction: conduction occurs across small gaps and point contacts between platelets and electrodes; this mechanism dominates when the film thickness is insufficient to generate a continuous network because tunnelling resistance and contact resistance scale strongly with inter-platelet gap and contact area.
• Adsorbate-assisted (ionic or moisture) surface conduction: conduction is mediated by adsorbed water or ionic species on the film surface; this is a different mechanism class because charge transport uses mobile ions or surface proton/hydroxide hopping rather than electronic delocalization through graphene planes, and it is more sensitive to environment.
• Bulk conductive-filler bridging (high loading, thick parts): conduction is established by many redundant three-dimensional contacts between fillers within the bulk; mechanism class differs because through-thickness redundancy makes the system insensitive to probe contact effects that dominate thin films.

Scope and Limitations

• Applies to: thin conductive coatings and surface-localized GNP/FLG layers on insulating substrates used in ESD and anti-static plastic finishes where film thickness is in the sub-micron to low-tens-of-micron range and the platelet morphology matches typical GNP/FLG distributions (see S1, S3, S6).
• Does not apply to: bulk, millimeter-thick composites or molded parts where through-thickness percolation is fully established and measurement probes sample true bulk conductivity; it also does not apply where continuous metallic coatings (e.g., vapor-deposited metal films) dominate conduction because mechanism is metallic film conduction rather than particulate percolation.
• When results may not transfer: if platelet lateral size, surface area, or layer count differ substantially from those in typical GNP/FLG grades (for example extremely large graphite flakes or highly oxidized graphene oxide), the percolation and contact resistance behaviour will change because aspect ratio and surface chemistry alter tunnelling distances and interplatelet adhesion.
• Physical / chemical pathway (separated): Absorption/collection: coating deposition places platelets within a binder or as a dry film; because platelets are conductive but discrete, absorption into a matrix determines spatial distribution. Energy conversion / charge transport: as a result conduction occurs via electronic hopping/tunnelling at low overlap, or via delocalized conduction when platelets overlap and form percolative paths. Material response: mechanical disturbance, humidity, or abrasion changes contact areas and gap distances; therefore as thickness decreases the film responds more like a collection of discrete contacts rather than a continuous conductor.
• Causal language summary: because thin films reduce the number of overlapping platelets, therefore inter-platelet contact resistance and tunnelling dominate, and as a result measured surface resistivity becomes highly sensitive to local dispersion, probe contact, and environment.

Related Links

Application page: Conductive & Anti-Static Coatings

Failure Modes

• Why particulate conductive fillers (e.g., carbon black) rapidly increase viscosity in conductive coatings in graphene nanoplatelet systems
• Why Carbon Black Eliminates Transparency or Clean Color in Anti-Static Coatings in graphene nanoplatelet systems
• Why graphitic particulate fillers sediment and cause conductivity drift in coatings in graphene nanoplatelet systems

Mechanism

• Mechanisms for surface-dominant conductive pathways in thin films in graphene nanoplatelet systems

Key Takeaways

• Film thickness controls measured surface resistivity.
• Observed: Surface resistivity is high and variable across parts even at nominally identical loading.
• Variable: Film thickness (absolute).

Engineer Questions

Q: What minimum film thickness ensures through-thickness percolation for GNP/FLG coatings?

A: There is no single universal thickness because percolation depends on platelet lateral size, volume fraction, and dispersion; therefore determine the practical minimum thickness experimentally for your grade and process by plotting sheet resistance versus thickness at fixed loading and reporting lateral position spread. Use platelet size distribution and specific surface area (SSA) data for your material (see S1,S6) to constrain test ranges before testing.

Q: Why do two-point and four-point measurements give different surface resistivity for thin graphene-nanoplate films?

A: Because for thin, surface-localized coatings probe contact resistance and electrode spacing are comparable to the film resistance; two-point includes contact resistance and probing-induced deformation while four-point reduces contact artefacts, therefore differences indicate that contact/tunnelling resistances and probe effects dominate at the tested thickness.

Q: Can increasing loading compensate for a very thin coating to reduce surface resistivity?

A: Increasing loading increases the probability of local percolation but may cause aggregation and roughness; therefore while higher loading can reduce resistivity in thin films, it can also create patchiness and mechanical/processing issues, so controlled trials and dispersion optimization are required rather than assuming linear scaling.

Q: How does platelet lateral size affect the thickness dependence of resistivity?

A: Larger lateral platelets increase overlap probability for a given thickness because each platelet spans more area; therefore films made from higher-aspect-ratio platelets achieve percolation at lower thickness compared with films made from smaller platelets (see platelet distribution evidence in S1, S3).

Q: What measurement practices reduce artefacts when evaluating thin anti-static coatings?

A: Use four-point or guarded measurements with standardized electrode spacing, control probe pressure and humidity, and measure sheet resistance as a function of film thickness and lateral position; these steps reduce the influence of contact resistance and environmental conduction which otherwise dominate thin-film results.

Q: When should I expect humidity to change my thin-film resistivity significantly?

A: Expect strong humidity sensitivity when the electronic conductive network is incomplete (thin films near or below percolation) because adsorbed moisture provides alternative ionic/adsorbate conduction paths; therefore if resistivity changes substantially with RH, the electronic percolation network is likely insufficient.